5 Reasons You Should Stop Doing HIIT Workouts to Move Past a Plateau

prefer to listen? Listen to the podcast episode HERE

High-intensity interval training (HIIT) is an incredibly popular workout format for its calorie-burning potential and efficient time commitment. But if you find yourself hitting a wall and feeling worn out, it may be time to rethink your reliance on HIIT. Here’s why doing too much HIIT could actually be slowing down your progress and what you should consider adding to your routine to see better results.

Reason #1: Overtraining Can Stall Progress

One of the biggest misconceptions about HIIT is that more is always better. Many people see the sweat, feel the burn, and assume they’re maximizing their progress. But over time, too much HIIT can actually work against your body by increasing stress levels and wearing down muscle tissues. When your body doesn’t have adequate time to recover, you may start experiencing muscle fatigue, exhaustion, and even weight gain due to elevated cortisol levels.

• Solution: To keep from overtraining, limit HIIT to 2-3 sessions per week, with each session lasting no more than 20 minutes. This allows your body time to recover between sessions, which is essential for both physical and mental energy.

Reason #2: HIIT Alone Doesn’t Build Muscle

While HIIT can torch calories and get your heart pumping, it doesn’t provide the same muscle-building benefits as strength training. To build a strong, lean body, you need to engage in muscle-focused exercises like strength or weight training. Otherwise, you risk a “skinny fat” appearance—where you may lose weight but lack the muscle tone and definition you’re after.

When you incorporate weight training into your fitness regimen, you’re engaging in exercises that stimulate muscle growth and contribute to a toned look. Muscle growth also improves your metabolism, helping you burn calories more effectively even when you’re at rest.

• Solution: Add 2-3 days of strength training to your weekly routine. Focus on compound movements like squats, deadlifts, and rows to build full-body strength.

Reason #3: HIIT Can Impact Stress Levels and Sleep Quality

There’s a fine line between the good stress (the challenge that encourages muscle and cardiovascular adaptation) and the bad stress that disrupts sleep and leaves you feeling drained. Excessive HIIT, with its high-energy output, can trigger an unhealthy response by raising cortisol levels. Too much cortisol doesn’t just wear on your mood and energy; it also disrupts sleep patterns, making it difficult for your body to recover.

Poor sleep quality can then turn into a cycle that hinders weight loss, increases cravings, and makes it harder to maintain a consistent workout routine.

• Solution: Incorporate low-intensity, low-stress activities like walking, stretching, or yoga. These activities can help reduce cortisol levels, improve sleep quality, and ensure that you’re rested enough to make the most of your HIIT and strength training workouts.

Reason #4: HIIT Can Lead to Fat Loss Plateaus

Our bodies are incredible at adapting to repetitive activities. While that adaptation is helpful in many ways, it can lead to a plateau in fat loss if you stick with the same exercise routine. Over time, your body becomes more efficient at performing HIIT workouts, meaning you’ll burn fewer calories compared to when you started. This is especially true if you’re doing the same kind of high-intensity workout without variations.

To avoid stagnation, a mix of workout types can stimulate fat loss and muscle growth, helping you to continue seeing results over the long term.

• Solution: Alternate between HIIT, strength training, and other forms of exercise. This variety will keep your body challenged and support sustained fat loss and muscle development. Adding different types of strength-based workouts can also keep your metabolism higher and improve overall calorie burn.

Reason #5: HIIT Increases the Risk of Injury

HIIT workouts are intense and often involve high-impact exercises that can strain your joints. The repetitive nature of some movements in HIIT, combined with the speed at which exercises are performed, can increase the risk of injuries. Overuse injuries are especially common if you’re pushing yourself to the limit without giving your body the time it needs to heal.

• Solution: Focus on quality over quantity. Use HIIT sparingly and add lower-impact workouts such as strength training to your regimen. Strength exercises with a focus on form and slower movement patterns are generally easier on your joints and can provide longer-term benefits without the same injury risk.

Practical Steps to Take

If HIIT has been your go-to workout, and you’re experiencing any of these setbacks, it might be time to switch things up. Remember, a balanced fitness approach is key to lasting results. Here’s a quick recap of how to adjust your routine:

1. Limit HIIT to 2-3 Days Per Week: Keep your sessions under 20 minutes and allow for 24-48 hours of recovery between workouts.
2. Increase Strength Training: Incorporate 2-3 days of strength training, focusing on full-body exercises like squats, lunges, and rows for muscle-building and metabolic benefits.
3. Prioritize Recovery: Include low-impact exercises like walking or yoga to help your body recover and reduce the risk of injury.
4. Listen to Your Body: If you feel exhausted, fatigued, or not making progress, it’s likely time to step back and re-evaluate.

Faith-Based Motivation for Simplifying Your Workouts

Our approach to fitness can parallel our walk with God. We often think doing more will get us closer to our goals, but sometimes the best thing we can do is simplify and be consistent. Just as we’re called to trust God’s timing and have patience, so too can we embrace a balanced approach in our fitness journey. Simplify where possible, lean into the basics, and trust the process.

Take the Quiz to Find Your Perfect Faith-Based Fitness Program!
If you’re wondering what program fits your current life season, take my Perfect Faith-Based Fitness Program Quiz. In just two minutes, you’ll have a tailored workout and nutrition plan designed to help you reach your goals sustainably.

Finding balance is essential to any fitness journey, especially when it comes to avoiding HIIT overkill. By adjusting your routine to include strength training, recovery, and balanced intensity, you’ll gain strength and endurance while reducing stress and risk of injury.